CaffeineShark
Alani Nu Witch's Brew

Alani Nu Witch's Brew

SHARK SCORE · EXCELLENT · SHARK SCORE · EXCELLENT · 86

Excellent · Buy it again without thinking.

Ranked #43 of 268 drinks · #5 of 9 Alani Nu

Sharks8.62 reviews Readers—Be the first

Reader scores count for up to 40%.

200 mgCaffeine
12 ozCan size
16.7mg per oz · Extreme
Check price on Amazon Rate it yourself

Paid link: we may earn a commission. Learn more

Your score

Had Alani Nu Witch's Brew? Tap a score. It counts toward the Shark Score the moment you post.

The Sharks’ verdict

Average of 2 Shark reviews. Each category is scored 0–10; Overall is its own call, not an average.

Look9.9/10
Taste8.4/10
Kick8.5/10
Overall8.6/10
JaredReviewed Oct 13, 2026
7.8/10
“Not my favorite combination of flavors, and I’m not a fan of how much the caramel lingers.”
Look10
Taste7.4
Kick9
Overall7.8

Jared’s full review

Introduction

Been meaning to try and review this one for a long time. Found it at 7-eleven.

Appearance

The can is awesome. Colorful, stands out, and fits the season perfectly.

Taste

Strong apple and caramel taste off the bat. Not exactly what I was expecting. My brain is dumb and expected something grape since the can is purple. The caramel carries into the aftertaste.

Kick

200mg of caffeine, which is ideal for me. Got a nice boost but not the best. I feel like I get a better kick from Celsius.

Conclusion

Not my favorite combination of flavors, and I’m not a fan of how much the caramel lingers. I think there will be a somewhat niche audience that loves this and gets sad if/when it’s only seasonal.

MattReviewed Oct 19, 2026
9.4/10
“The perfect tribute to spooky season, both delicious and fun”
Look9.8
Taste9.4
Kick8
Overall9.4
Read Matt’s full review

Appearance

Appropriately on theme, the latest version with the chrome cauldron and tentacle monster are top notch

Taste

Captures the essence of candy apples perfectly

Kick

Alani Nu Witch’s Brew has 200mg of caffeine, approximately equivalent to two cups of coffee.

Overall

The perfect tribute to spooky season, both delicious and fun. Why have a caramel covered apple when you can have this? It’s not a surprise that they are difficult to obtain.

Not reviewed yet by CamAsk for a review

Alani Nu Witch's Brew: quick answers

How much caffeine is in Alani Nu Witch's Brew?

Alani Nu Witch's Brew has 200 mg of caffeine in a 12 fl oz can (16.7 mg per fluid ounce). That's about as much as 2 cups of brewed coffee (8 oz each, about 95 mg per cup), 50% of the 400 mg a day the FDA cites for healthy adults. It ranks #70 for caffeine among the 268 drinks we've rated.

Is Alani Nu Witch's Brew sugar-free?

Yes. Alani Nu Witch's Brew is a zero-sugar drink. Formulas change, so check the can's nutrition panel if sugar matters to you.

Is Alani Nu Witch's Brew good?

The Sharks give Alani Nu Witch's Brew a Shark Score of 86 (Excellent: “Buy it again without thinking.”), ranking it #43 of 268. The short version: “Not my favorite combination of flavors, and I’m not a fan of how much the caramel lingers.”

What is the best Alani Nu flavor?

Of the 9 Alani Nu drinks we've rated, the best is Alani Nu Mimosa (93). Alani Nu Witch's Brew ranks #5. The lowest-rated is Alani Nu Strawberry Sunrise (62). See every Alani Nu flavor ranked.

More from Alani Nu

All 9 Alani Nu drinks

Similar drinks from other brands

Close in caffeine per ounce, also sugar-free, and scored near 86.

Caffeine chart